POZ Exclusive: Judge Rules In Favor Of A Day To Remember In Court Case V. Victory Records

by Zack Zarrillo - Oct 4, 2013

image

PropertyOfZack has just received word from trusted sources that A Day To Remember have officially won their near two-year long court case against Victory Records. 

This story is developing and will be updated with more details as we learn more information on the matter.

Update: We have changed our headline from “A Day To Remember Win Ruling Against Victory Records” to “Judge Rules In Favor Of A Day To Remember In Court Case v. Victory Records” until more details surface.

Update #2: Victory Records’ lawyer has issued a statement to AbsolutePunk. It can be read below after the jump.

To clarify update #2: Based off of Victory’s lawyer’s statement, A Day To Remember are allowed to self-release Common Courtesy, but Victory may end up receiving the profits from the album if the court further decides that the band owes the label two albums. 

Update #3ADTR Confirm Self-Release Of ‘Common Courtesy’

Related Stories:
A Day To Remember Case Reportedly Left To The Judge To Decide
A Day To Remember, Victory Records Court Case Postponed

Judgement Day: Will ‘Common Courtesy’ Be Released Next Week?
 

While Victory is disappointed with the ruling, and disagrees with the court’s conclusions, it comes as no surprise. Courts rarely grant negative injunctions of this nature, but the circumstances of this case presented a unique opportunity for such a ruling. Having said that, in denying Victory’s motion, the court’s reasoning actually contained silver linings that significantly favored Victory. First, the court held that it supports Victory’sargument about the construction of the recording contract – that ADTR is still obligated to deliver two more albums to Victory — “at last equally, if not more so, than that offered by ADTR.” That is the core issue in this case and the only one that really matters in the end, so Victory is heartened that the court agreed with Victory’s position on that core issue. Also, the sole basis for the court’s denial of the injunction was that Victory would not suffer “irreparable harm” that could not be compensated by money damages if the album were to be self released, in that it has ample evidence to prove its damages against the band (in the form of lost profits if ADTR does proceed to self release Common Courtesy). That is, even if the band self releases it, Victory is likely to be awarded any profits the band makes on that album, plus additional lost profits suffered by Victory based on the fact that Victory would undeniably do a far better job at marketing the album had Victory released it, which is what Victory is known for and is the reason why ADTR signed with Victory in the first place. In sum, it is a “successful” defeat in a way, and one which Victory welcomed because of the manner in which the Court rendered its opinion.

This case will proceed to trial, and Victory is looking forward to the opportunity to vindicate the baseless claims filed by ADTR. 
-Robert S. Meloni

  1. simon--riley reblogged this from propertyofzack
  2. bandoozi reblogged this from propertyofzack
  3. naoches reblogged this from mrs-mckinnonroetter
  4. mrs-mckinnonroetter reblogged this from adaytofucking--remember
  5. kelseycarlsonnn reblogged this from poop-punk-or-die
  6. poop-punk-or-die reblogged this from propertyofzack
  7. kerstynnlane reblogged this from propertyofzack
  8. ecstasyvi reblogged this from propertyofzack
  9. gunslingers-journey reblogged this from propertyofzack
  10. b3aun3r reblogged this from monstersanddepression
  11. no-happy-medium reblogged this from propertyofzack
  12. adaytofucking--remember reblogged this from propertyofzack
  13. macklenotmuch reblogged this from propertyofzack
  14. kianashanel reblogged this from fascicinate
  15. so-long-spencer reblogged this from propertyofzack and added:
    LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOO
  16. eozredavni reblogged this from breakingdads
  17. headgotmisplaced reblogged this from propertyofzack
  18. breakingdads reblogged this from propertyofzack
  19. poison-0ak reblogged this from wakaflackalypse
  20. gnarlyjedi reblogged this from propertyofzack
  21. itsmattyeaah reblogged this from propertyofzack
  22. onetimeimetjackbarakat reblogged this from propertyofzack
  23. dseagull reblogged this from propertyofzack and added:
    Interesting. Though it is a legal victory for ADTR, they may be forced to release with Victory anyway due to the nature...
  24. adayto-f0rget reblogged this from isaididneverletyoufall and added:
    HAPPY TODAY THIS MADE MY DAY !!!!!
  25. halfsquat851 reblogged this from propertyofzack and added:
    Fuck Victory, we won, Common Courtesy Oct. 8th.
  26. fascicinate reblogged this from alisonlikescats
Ernie Ball